top of page
Search

The Best Toys for Shy Cats: Making Playtime Comfortable and Fun!

Shy cats hold a special place in my heart, as an introvert myself, I completely relate to how uncomfortable meeting new people can be... And I feel the most accomplished when a shy kitty completely opens up to me and engages in active playtime. As a dedicated cat lover and experienced cat sitter, I've had the pleasure of spending time with many feline friends. One of the most fascinating aspects of cats is their unique personalities: I've taken care of many cats and not two of them have had the same personality. While some cats are outgoing and demand constant attention (yes, some cats are truly all up on your business), others are shy and hesitant, especially around new people. This shyness can stem from past trauma or simply be a part of their personality. I do want to emphasize that it's not a negative trait, it simply means you have to work towards earning their trust.


Understanding their needs is crucial in helping shy cats feel safe and comfortable, calming diffusers is one thing that has helped me a lot when boarding cats, and I always recommend it to parents with shy cats (sadly, I don't get affiliate commission for my recommendations).


I’ve discovered through my time being a cat sitter for friends, family, and my community that finding the right toys can really make a difference! Here are my top recommendations for toys that shy cats tend to love:





  1. String Toys

String toys are often a hit with shy cats. The gentle swaying and movement of the string can intrigue them without overwhelming them. Here are some key features to consider when choosing string toys:


  • No Attachments: I was playing with this wand toy that had a short string and a feather attachment which my cat destroyed in no time, I was left with just the string and surprisingly he LOVED it. I tried it with a few shy cats and they also absolutely loved it, as soon as I added any sort of attachments, they became hesitant and some scared.

  • Supervised play only. Do not leave string toys out and about because they can accidentally swallow it. I left the toy out for a moment and my cat decided it was a snack, when I came back, he had already swallowed almost half of it. Thankfully everything was fine, it was just very unpleasant to have to pull it out and wash it.





  1. Laser Pointers

Laser pointers are another great option for shy cats, but they're not as popular as string toys. Some cats are very unimpressed by it to say the least. They provide an interactive way for your cat to engage in play without direct confrontation. Something I've found helpful is laying treats around the play area and having the laser guide them to the treats.


Here’s why lasers work:

  • No Pressure: Since the laser is controlled by you, cats can engage at their own comfort level, allowing for organic play without the stress of a chase.

  • Energy Outlet: Chasing a laser dot can help shy cats burn off energy and gain confidence in their surroundings.





  1. Soft Plush Toys

While shy cats may not initially engage with toys, soft plush toys can be a comforting presence. Consider:


  • Familiarity: Introduce plush toys gradually to help your cat build trust. Soft textures can be soothing and inviting. I usually spray some catnip either in spray form or sprinkle some on top.

  • Interactive Options: Some plush toys come with a crinkle sound or are infused with catnip, which can entice your shy kitty to explore them further.


Tips to Remember

As much as shy cats may enjoy these toys, it’s essential to remember what to avoid:


Avoid Toys with Bells: Bells can be alarming for many shy cats. The sudden noise can trigger their flight response, making them feel unsafe. Stick to quieter toys that allow for gentle play.


Being a cat sitter has truly allowed me to observe and appreciate the distinct personalities of our feline friends. When it comes to shy cats, understanding their needs and preferences is key to finding the perfect toys for them. By introducing gentle toys like string toys, laser pointers, and plush comforts, you can help your shy kitty feel more at ease and encourage them to come out of their shell during play. 


Remember, every cat is unique, so make sure to pay attention to their individual reactions and preferences. There no better feeling than when a shy cat finds safety and comfort in you, their cat parent.


Cat Lover? checkout some of our purrfect little items





 
 

Comments


bottom of page